Best Betta Fish Filters; The AAP Sponge Filter

Many affiliate blogs will promote HOB or Internal Filters as the optimum choice for a Betta Fish Filter.
HOWEVER, the truly best filter for a Betta fish based on real world experience such as that of Aquarium keeping expert and author Carl Strohmeyer, is the Sponge Filter.

Even then, among sponge filters the USA made AAP Hydro Sponge should be your first choice.
As for type, the fine generally is your best choice since it will trap finer debris and has a slightly higher bio load capacity.
This said, if you want the optimum sponge filter, a combo fine/coarse would be your best choice, such as pictured below [1/3 PRO Combo from AAP].
Beware of social media sellers that promote ONLY coarse Chinese made sponge filters, which have their place but certainly are not the best choice for a Betta fish.

WHY THE SPONGE FILTER?

Sponger Filters are much less likely to cause damage to delicate Betta Fins, especially the tail fin.
Despite the popular social media myth about stress induced Betta tail biting that is further perpetuated by search engines [especially Bing's highly inaccurate Bing AI], damage caused by filter intakes is one of the leading cause of betta tail damage according to experts over the decades.

A little more about this myth, especially since it has picked up steam of late;
Stress induced betta tail biting has been considered and proven a myth for decades.
To date, no video evidence has been presented to prove this myth is actually true, as all videos that show a betta biting itself are clearly acts of aggression, generally from reflections of the same betta in the aquarium/bowl glass.
MOREOVER, science dictates that it is the person who is trying to disprove established science to present evidence that their theory is the correct one. NOT THE OTHERWAY AROUND as many now would have you believe, even search engines such as Bing [whom now censors many science based aquarium keeping websites so as to present the false truth they want you to believe]. And as noted, the decades long established science has been that betta fish do not bite their tails due to stress like a dog or bird might do.

BACK TO THE SUBJECT AT HAND, sponge filters for betta fish; these filters are among the best bio filters for their size and also they do not attract Aeromonas bacteria like some filters can. Which, Aeromonas bacteria infections are among the other leading causes fo betta fin damage and even death.

Sponge filters also work well in bare bottom aquariums which can help with ease of cleaning and lowing the amount of mulm in an aquarium [which can also attract Aeromonas bacteria].

So in summary, in most instances, your best choice for a betta fish filter is a sponge filter [fine or combo]. And why not buy from the decades long leader in aquarium keeping information; AAP, rather than the many lower quality knock offs from China now flooding the market?

Resource for the best USA made Sponge Filters;
AAP Hydro sponge Filters

Further Reading as per expanding upon information provided in this short article:
*Stress Induced Betta Fish Tail Biting; Myth or Fact
*The Myth of Stress Induced Betta Tail Biting; From Fish as Pets
*Fish Aeromonas & Vibrio Disease | Septicemia | Pop Eye | Treatment
*Fin & Tail Rot in Bettas & other Fish; Treatment and Prevention

Aquarium Sponge Filter Made in USA or China

With many now jumping on the bandwagon of attempting to usurp the AAP/ATI Hydro Sponge Filter patent, the first question a potential buyer needs to ask is why purchase a knock off product made in China (even if sold under a USA name).

As well, while the basics of the patent design have been copied pretty much accurately, the sponge material is not the same and has much lower capacity, so in the end, you still get an inferior product!

What is also unfortunate, is many pushing these Chinese knock offs have little to no professional experience or mentoring in their use.
Otherwise why would you have the latest promoter of a new knock off bragging that they only utilize the reticulated (coarse) sponge?
The facts remain that often the more fine is the better choice for both mechanical & bio filtration, even in larger aquariums. As well, even more often the use of one of each or the unique AAP Combo Hydro Sponge Filters is your best choice (these combine both sponge filter types in one filter).

So I ask again, why not purchase the best Aquarium Sponge Filter which includes a complete line of both sponge material types, combos, as well as pre-filters and pond /aquarium system models that no one else makes or sells and get the added benefit of knowing you are promoting a 100% "made in the USA" product over China (note that the AAP/ATI Hydro Sponge Filter is 100% American made).
In the end, if a popular YouTube personality promotes something, it does not make it the best. Support the professional aquarium industry and American made products!!

References:
Aquarium Sponge Filter Use, Sponge Filtration

10 Pro and Cons of Aquarium Sponge Filters

Resources:
Aquarium Sponge Filters by ATI/AAP

Filter Max, Sponge Pre-Filters

Hydro Pond Sponge Filters | Central Aquarium System Sump Filters

---

ADVERTISEMENT

---

How to Connect Filter Max to Aquarium Filter Intake

 

Sponge Filters such as the patented design AAP Filter Max that use high performance sponge material make excellent pre-filters that fit most HOB Aquarium Power Filters as well as power-heads and internal water pumps (such as the Rio line).
These can keep your bio filter running when changing cartridges and add to your current bio filtration all the while keeping fry from being sucked into the intake

HOWEVER, sometimes, even with the many adapters included, it may be difficult for some to fit these onto their filters.
This is the point of this brief article is to show several different options (and far from a finite number of options too) as to how to adapter the AAP Filter Max to your aquarium filter intake tube.
As the reader will note, many suggestions recommend Teflon Tape for a tighter fit (which most persons have on hand or is readily available). One picture shows the use of 3/4" ID flexible tubing which is not included, otherwise everything else is included.

Please click on the picture to enlarge for a better view

Please note that there are UNAUTHORIZED sellers of this aquarium pre-filter such as over at Amazon. These sellers are 2nd hand sellers, so chances of damaged products is a real possibility.
With authorized sellers such as American Aquarium Products, damage is less than 1 out of 250 filters and is quickly taken care of by their excellent customer service that is monitored on weekends and evenings too.
So be wary of less than accurate Amazon Reviews as to broken parts for this second to none aquarium pre-filter

RECOMMENDED RESOURCE:
AAP Filter Max Aquarium Pre-Filters

Other resource:
Rio Plus Pumps from AAP

Recommended Reading for serious aquarium keepers:
*Sponge Filtration; Use & more
*Freshwater Aquarium Basics
*Buying Aquarium Products via Amazon
*Why to not purchase aquarium products from Amazon
*Amazon Reviews For aquarium products

What Does a Patented Aquarium Sponge Filter Mean?

With the flood of cheap (1) Chinese knock offs, (2) patent infringing copies (Patent 5203990), and (3) long time competitors that are simply less efficient; the answer is A LOT!

One thing all three have in common is a poor sponge material design, which is also how costs are shaved!
I have seen YouTube comments by persons who only know these sponge filters by the above noted categories, not by the use of a patented AAP/Hydro Sponge Filter.

With a poorly designed sponge, much of the muck that is held by the sponge is trapped in the outer part of the sponge. A good test is when the sponge is removed, a good portion drips back into the aquarium if not removed very carefully. Then when rinsing, it does not take much to clean these sponges.

With a patented AAP/Hydro Sponge, generally the same amount of muck might drip back into the aquarium upon removal, however the big difference is when rinsing and squeezing to get clean in a small bucket of used aquarium water (or de-chlorinated water), it often takes 2 or 3 water changes in this bucket for the sponge to come clean!!!

The picture below demonstrates the high density of sponge pores found in a quality sponge. This is unlike most every other sponge which have more in common with the foam in your couch cushion!



Let's look at each of these in a bit more detail:

1. Cheap Chinese Knock Offs: Here we have often poor filter design combined with already noted poor sponge design. The result is poor flow patterns and inefficiency of the filter in both mechanical and biological filtration. Often resulting in less than 1/4 the capacity of better sponge filters. An example is the XY-380 often sold on eBay or Amazon


2. Patent infringing copies: Here we again still generally see a poor sponge used to save on production cost for much lower capacity of bio and mechanical filtration. HOWEVER because the patented interchangeable design has been copied, flow patterns and versatility are definitely better.
   Sadly Hydro-Sponge has ceased battling many of these companies infringing on their patent here due to time and money involved (not to mention that while AAP/Hydro Sponge is 100% American made, it is nearly impossible to stop patent infringement in China for low cost goods).
   
   What we can do is avoid these companies and stores that sell these.
   Unfortunately in our often social media driven world, we have aquarium marketing schemes de-jour such as "My Aquarium Box" actively promoting just one such patent infringer. As well as popular YouTubers such as Aquarium Cop-op re-branding Chinese made copycats with inferior sponge material and claiming that only coarse filter material should be used as it is better when in fact in many cases it is not the best choice and more often than not, a combination of fine and coarse clearly is best.
   We also have a popular blogger who has very well written articles on fish care and implies expertise with "Labs" in the title. Unfortunately, he too promotes Amazon Chinese knock offs. Worse yet, when confronted, he goes off on a "Red Herring" argument about how often AAP updates their page as a way to somehow discredit the content, which this has no bearing on the subject (as well the content on the AAP website has been updated often, in past on this subject, prior to the sale of the business, it was updated on average every 6 months which is far more than any other author of quality aquarium keeping information).
   
   In the end, we need persons in this hobby who will listen to others who have been around a long time to mentor them and and then follow the trail of truth.
   
   


3. Long time competitors that are simply less efficient: This is where sponge filters such as the Lees, Hagen, and Tetra fall based on my mentors experiments. While these and others have been around for a long time, their flow patterns simply do not allow the versatility of use nor the flow rates of the patented AAP/Hydro Sponge Filter. These filters also do not use the quality of sponge material, albeit better than all the Chinese knock offs, thus lowering mechanical and biological sponge filter capacity

Further Reading:
Sponge Filter Information

Recommended Resource for Patented Sponge Filters:
AAP Hydro Sponge Filters

Genuine AAP Hydro Sponge #2 PRO; Only Authorized eBay Seller

Related Information:
Common Aquarium Keeping Myths